Multi-Focus on Practices 2, 3, and 4
Connect an experiment to a two-proportion interval: FRQ
3 versions of one AP Statistics free-response question, each with a 10-point rubric and a model answer for every point. Write your response on paper before you open the rubric.
These are StatsLearn originals written in the AP style, not released exam questions. Topics: 1.13 Experimental Design, 3.10 Constructing a Confidence Interval for the Difference Between Two Population Proportions, 3.11 Justifying a Claim Based on a Confidence Interval for the Difference Between Two Population Proportions.
Version 1
A health program recruits 290 volunteers and randomly assigns 140 to text reminders and 150 to email reminders. In the text group, 87 attend a follow-up visit. In the email group, 72 attend. Use z* = 1.96.
- (a) Explain what random assignment permits and what volunteer recruitment does not permit.
- (b) Calculate both sample proportions and check the large-count condition.
- (c) Construct the confidence interval for the difference in population proportions.
- (d) Interpret what the interval supports in this study.
Show the rubric and model answers
Part (a): 2 points
- Explains the purpose of random assignment. Random assignment uses chance to distribute other variables between reminder groups, supporting a causal comparison for these volunteers.
- States the scope of inference correctly. The design supports causation for the volunteers, but volunteer recruitment does not support generalization to a wider population.
Part (b): 3 points
- Computes the text-group proportion. p-hat1 = 87/140 = 0.6214.
- Computes the email-group proportion. p-hat2 = 72/150 = 0.4800.
- Checks the large-count condition for both groups. The four counts 87, 53, 72, and 78 are each at least 10.
Part (c): 4 points
- Uses the observed difference and computes the unpooled standard error. The interval is centered at 0.1414, and SE = 0.0578.
- Computes the margin of error. ME = 1.96(0.0578) = 0.1133.
- Computes the lower endpoint. Lower endpoint = 0.0281.
- Computes the upper endpoint. Upper endpoint = 0.2548.
Part (d): 1 point
- Uses the interval to make the supported conclusion. Because the entire interval is above zero, the data support a higher follow-up rate for text reminders among these volunteers.
Version 2
A health program recruits 370 volunteers and randomly assigns 180 to text reminders and 190 to email reminders. In the text group, 115 attend a follow-up visit. In the email group, 94 attend. Use z* = 1.96.
- (a) Explain what random assignment permits and what volunteer recruitment does not permit.
- (b) Calculate both sample proportions and check the large-count condition.
- (c) Construct the confidence interval for the difference in population proportions.
- (d) Interpret what the interval supports in this study.
Show the rubric and model answers
Part (a): 2 points
- Explains the purpose of random assignment. Random assignment uses chance to distribute other variables between reminder groups, supporting a causal comparison for these volunteers.
- States the scope of inference correctly. The design supports causation for the volunteers, but volunteer recruitment does not support generalization to a wider population.
Part (b): 3 points
- Computes the text-group proportion. p-hat1 = 115/180 = 0.6389.
- Computes the email-group proportion. p-hat2 = 94/190 = 0.4947.
- Checks the large-count condition for both groups. The four counts 115, 65, 94, and 96 are each at least 10.
Part (c): 4 points
- Uses the observed difference and computes the unpooled standard error. The interval is centered at 0.1442, and SE = 0.0510.
- Computes the margin of error. ME = 1.96(0.0510) = 0.0999.
- Computes the lower endpoint. Lower endpoint = 0.0443.
- Computes the upper endpoint. Upper endpoint = 0.2440.
Part (d): 1 point
- Uses the interval to make the supported conclusion. Because the entire interval is above zero, the data support a higher follow-up rate for text reminders among these volunteers.
Version 3
A health program recruits 450 volunteers and randomly assigns 220 to text reminders and 230 to email reminders. In the text group, 145 attend a follow-up visit. In the email group, 118 attend. Use z* = 1.96.
- (a) Explain what random assignment permits and what volunteer recruitment does not permit.
- (b) Calculate both sample proportions and check the large-count condition.
- (c) Construct the confidence interval for the difference in population proportions.
- (d) Interpret what the interval supports in this study.
Show the rubric and model answers
Part (a): 2 points
- Explains the purpose of random assignment. Random assignment uses chance to distribute other variables between reminder groups, supporting a causal comparison for these volunteers.
- States the scope of inference correctly. The design supports causation for the volunteers, but volunteer recruitment does not support generalization to a wider population.
Part (b): 3 points
- Computes the text-group proportion. p-hat1 = 145/220 = 0.6591.
- Computes the email-group proportion. p-hat2 = 118/230 = 0.5130.
- Checks the large-count condition for both groups. The four counts 145, 75, 118, and 112 are each at least 10.
Part (c): 4 points
- Uses the observed difference and computes the unpooled standard error. The interval is centered at 0.1460, and SE = 0.0459.
- Computes the margin of error. ME = 1.96(0.0459) = 0.0900.
- Computes the lower endpoint. Lower endpoint = 0.0561.
- Computes the upper endpoint. Upper endpoint = 0.2360.
Part (d): 1 point
- Uses the interval to make the supported conclusion. Because the entire interval is above zero, the data support a higher follow-up rate for text reminders among these volunteers.
Keep going
- Score yourself on more versions in the FRQ trainer
- Design a causal school study: AP Stats FRQ practice
- Build and evaluate a probability simulation: FRQ practice
- Compare two quantitative distributions: FRQ practice
- Analyze a regression model: AP Stats FRQ practice
- Carry out a one-proportion z-test: AP Stats FRQ practice
- Construct a one-mean t interval: AP Stats FRQ practice
- Synthesize sampling, probability, and regression: FRQ
- Calculating the mean: AP Stats multiple choice practice
- Interquartile range (IQR): AP Stats multiple choice practice
- z-scores: AP Stats multiple choice practice
- Scope of inference: AP Stats multiple choice practice
- Sampling bias: AP Stats multiple choice practice
- Mean of the sampling distribution of p-hat multiple choice
- Standard deviation of p-hat: multiple choice practice
- Margin of error for a proportion: multiple choice practice
- One-proportion z-test statistic: multiple choice practice
- Standard error for two proportions: multiple choice practice
- Chi-square expected counts: multiple choice practice
- p-value and alpha decisions: multiple choice practice