Multi-Focus on Practices 3 and 4

Compare two quantitative distributions: FRQ practice

3 versions of one AP Statistics free-response question, each with a 10-point rubric and a model answer for every point. Write your response on paper before you open the rubric.

These are StatsLearn originals written in the AP style, not released exam questions. Topics: 1.6 Descriptions for One Quantitative Variable Distributions, 1.7 Summary Statistics for One Quantitative Variable, 1.9 Comparisons of the Distributions for One Quantitative Variable.

Version 1

Two tutoring groups recorded the number of minutes students practiced in one week. Group A has five-number summary 11, 18, 24, 30, 52 and mean 26.4. Group B has five-number summary 11, 16, 21, 25, 31 and mean 21.4.

  1. (a) Compare the centers of the two groups in context.
  2. (b) Calculate and compare spread using the IQR, and calculate Group A's range.
  3. (c) Check Group A's maximum for an outlier and explain how it affects the summaries.
Show the rubric and model answers

Part (a): 2 points

  • Computes the difference in medians. The median difference A minus B is 24 - 21 = 3.0 minutes.
  • Compares centers in context. Group A has the higher typical practice time because its median is larger.

Part (b): 4 points

  • Computes Group A's IQR. IQR A = 30 - 18 = 12.0 minutes.
  • Computes Group B's IQR. IQR B = 25 - 16 = 9.0 minutes.
  • Compares variability using the IQRs. Group A is more variable in the middle half because its IQR is larger.
  • Computes Group A's range. Range A = 52 - 11 = 41.0 minutes.

Part (c): 4 points

  • Computes Group A's upper outlier fence. Upper fence A = 30 + 1.5(12) = 48.0.
  • Classifies Group A's maximum using the fence. 52 is above 48.0, so it is a high outlier by the 1.5 IQR rule.
  • Explains the outlier's effect on mean and median. Removing the high outlier would lower the mean more than the median because the mean uses every magnitude and the median is resistant.
  • Gives a complete contextual comparison. Group A has the higher center and larger middle-half spread, but its high outlier helps explain why its mean sits farther above its median.

Version 2

Two tutoring groups recorded the number of minutes students practiced in one week. Group A has five-number summary 15, 22, 28, 34, 56 and mean 30.4. Group B has five-number summary 15, 20, 25, 29, 35 and mean 25.4.

  1. (a) Compare the centers of the two groups in context.
  2. (b) Calculate and compare spread using the IQR, and calculate Group A's range.
  3. (c) Check Group A's maximum for an outlier and explain how it affects the summaries.
Show the rubric and model answers

Part (a): 2 points

  • Computes the difference in medians. The median difference A minus B is 28 - 25 = 3.0 minutes.
  • Compares centers in context. Group A has the higher typical practice time because its median is larger.

Part (b): 4 points

  • Computes Group A's IQR. IQR A = 34 - 22 = 12.0 minutes.
  • Computes Group B's IQR. IQR B = 29 - 20 = 9.0 minutes.
  • Compares variability using the IQRs. Group A is more variable in the middle half because its IQR is larger.
  • Computes Group A's range. Range A = 56 - 15 = 41.0 minutes.

Part (c): 4 points

  • Computes Group A's upper outlier fence. Upper fence A = 34 + 1.5(12) = 52.0.
  • Classifies Group A's maximum using the fence. 56 is above 52.0, so it is a high outlier by the 1.5 IQR rule.
  • Explains the outlier's effect on mean and median. Removing the high outlier would lower the mean more than the median because the mean uses every magnitude and the median is resistant.
  • Gives a complete contextual comparison. Group A has the higher center and larger middle-half spread, but its high outlier helps explain why its mean sits farther above its median.

Version 3

Two tutoring groups recorded the number of minutes students practiced in one week. Group A has five-number summary 19, 26, 32, 38, 60 and mean 34.4. Group B has five-number summary 19, 24, 29, 33, 39 and mean 29.4.

  1. (a) Compare the centers of the two groups in context.
  2. (b) Calculate and compare spread using the IQR, and calculate Group A's range.
  3. (c) Check Group A's maximum for an outlier and explain how it affects the summaries.
Show the rubric and model answers

Part (a): 2 points

  • Computes the difference in medians. The median difference A minus B is 32 - 29 = 3.0 minutes.
  • Compares centers in context. Group A has the higher typical practice time because its median is larger.

Part (b): 4 points

  • Computes Group A's IQR. IQR A = 38 - 26 = 12.0 minutes.
  • Computes Group B's IQR. IQR B = 33 - 24 = 9.0 minutes.
  • Compares variability using the IQRs. Group A is more variable in the middle half because its IQR is larger.
  • Computes Group A's range. Range A = 60 - 19 = 41.0 minutes.

Part (c): 4 points

  • Computes Group A's upper outlier fence. Upper fence A = 38 + 1.5(12) = 56.0.
  • Classifies Group A's maximum using the fence. 60 is above 56.0, so it is a high outlier by the 1.5 IQR rule.
  • Explains the outlier's effect on mean and median. Removing the high outlier would lower the mean more than the median because the mean uses every magnitude and the median is resistant.
  • Gives a complete contextual comparison. Group A has the higher center and larger middle-half spread, but its high outlier helps explain why its mean sits farther above its median.

Keep going