Choosing mean vs median and SD vs IQR worksheet with answers

8 problems on choosing mean vs median and SD vs IQR, ready to print for class or homework. The answer key prints on its own page, so hand out everything before it.

Problem 1

A nursery measures the height, in centimeters, of 11 seedlings from one tray: 23, 21, 26, 19, 23, 24, 22, 27, 23, 20, 25. Treat them as a sample. (a) Find the mean, the median, the standard deviation, and the IQR. (b) Which measure of center and which measure of variability should the nursery report, and what in the data justifies the choice?

Problem 2

A school club lists the 10 gifts, in dollars, its one-day online fundraiser received: 20, 15, 275, 12, 30, 10, 40, 18, 25, 15. (a) Find the mean, the median, the standard deviation, and the IQR. (b) The club newsletter wants one sentence about the typical gift. Which pair of summaries should it use, and what in the data settles that?

Problem 3

A 10-person office logs each employee's commute, in minutes: 43, 8, 45, 7, 41, 9, 44, 6, 42, 8. (a) Find the mean and the median. (b) A manager argues that the mean and the median are within half a minute of each other, so the distribution must be roughly symmetric and the mean with the standard deviation is safe to report. Test that argument against the sorted data. (c) What should the office report instead?

Problem 4

A bakery times how long 8 loaves take to cool, in minutes: 35, 31, 38, 34, 40, 33, 37, 36. (a) Find the mean, the median, the standard deviation, and the IQR for those 8 loaves. (b) A ninth loaf, baked in a much larger tin, took 94 minutes. Before computing, predict which of the four summaries moves most. Then recompute all four with all 9 loaves. (c) What does the comparison show?

Problem 5

A soil lab weighs the dry mass, in grams, of 9 core samples: 32, 27, 38, 24, 36, 31, 37, 29, 34. The 24-gram core is re-weighed after the technician sees that it had been crumbling, and the corrected mass is 6 grams. No other value changes. First say which of the mean, median, Q1Q_1, Q3Q_3, IQR, and standard deviation must change. Then compute each one before and after and check the prediction.

Problem 6

A 9-person design studio pays annual salaries, in dollars, of 36000, 34000, 41000, 32000, 44000, 38000, 196000, 35000, and 39000, the largest belonging to the owner. (a) A job seeker asks what a typical person there earns. (b) The bookkeeper needs the total salary cost for next year's budget. Which measure of center answers each question, and what number does each one get?

Problem 7

A hospital publishes summary statistics for the length of stay, in days, of 4,200 admissions: mean 6.4 days, median 3 days, standard deviation 7.9 days, minimum 1 day, Q1=2Q_1 = 2 days, Q3=6Q_3 = 6 days, maximum 96 days. No graph is published. (a) A reporter wants one number for a typical stay. Which should the reporter use, and why? (b) Use the 1.5 IQR rule to show that at least one stay is an outlier and that no stay can be flagged at the low end. (c) What do these summaries settle about the shape, and what do they leave open?

Problem 8

A writer records the number of comments on each of 12 blog posts: 28, 25, 31, 22, 118, 27, 30, 24, 34, 25, 33, 29. (a) Find the mean, the median, the standard deviation, and the IQR. (b) Which pair should the writer report, and what in the data justifies it? (c) The 118-comment post was linked by a large newsletter. Recompute all four summaries without it and say how far each one moved. (d) A classmate claims that whenever the mean and the median are close, the mean and the standard deviation are safe to report. Judge that claim using the commute data in problem 3.

Choosing mean vs median and SD vs IQR: answer key

  1. (a) Mean 23 cm, median 23 cm, s=6≈2.45s = \sqrt{6} \approx 2.45 cm, IQR=4IQR = 4 cm. (b) Report the mean and the standard deviation. The distribution is close to symmetric, the mean and median land on the same value, and the 1.5 IQR rule flags nothing, so no extreme value is pulling the mean away from the center of the data.

  2. (a) Mean 46 dollars, median 19 dollars, s≈80.97s \approx 80.97 dollars, IQR=15IQR = 15 dollars. (b) Report the median and the IQR. The 275-dollar gift is an outlier by the 1.5 IQR rule, and it pushed the mean above 9 of the 10 gifts and pushed ss past the whole range of the rest, so the newsletter should say the typical gift was about 19 dollars with the middle half between 15 and 30 dollars.

  3. (a) Mean 25.3 minutes, median 25 minutes. (b) The argument fails. The sorted data splits into a cluster of 6 to 9 minutes and a cluster of 41 to 45 minutes with nothing between, and the nearest commute to the mean is 15.7 minutes away. The 1.5 IQR rule flags no outliers, so a clean outlier check is no evidence of symmetry either. (c) Report the two clusters separately and describe the shape, because no single center or spread describes this office.

  4. (a) Mean 35.5 minutes, median 35.5 minutes, s≈2.88s \approx 2.88 minutes, IQR=4IQR = 4 minutes. (b) Predict the mean and the standard deviation, since both use the value 94 itself. With the 94-minute loaf: mean 42 minutes, median 36 minutes, s≈19.69s \approx 19.69 minutes, IQR=5.5IQR = 5.5 minutes. (c) The mean rose 6.5 minutes against the median's 0.5, and ss grew about 6.8 times while the IQR moved 1.5 minutes. The resistant pair shifted a little rather than not at all, and the mean now exceeds 8 of the 9 cooling times, so report the median and the IQR while the 94-minute loaf is in the data.

  5. Only the mean and the standard deviation change: the mean falls from 32 to 30 grams (a drop of 18/9=218/9 = 2) and ss rises from 22.5≈4.74\sqrt{22.5} \approx 4.74 to 94.5≈9.72\sqrt{94.5} \approx 9.72 grams. The median stays 32 grams and Q1=28Q_1 = 28, Q3=36.5Q_3 = 36.5, IQR=8.5IQR = 8.5 grams all hold, because the corrected value is still the smallest and no other value changed position. The unchanged fences of 15.25 and 49.25 grams now flag the 6-gram core, which the 24-gram reading was not.

  6. (a) The median, 38,000 dollars, paired with the IQR of 8,000 dollars. The 196,000-dollar salary is an outlier past the 54,500-dollar fence, and it lifts the mean to 55,000 dollars, above 8 of the 9 salaries. (b) The mean, 55,000 dollars, because total payroll is 9×55,000=495,0009 \times 55{,}000 = 495{,}000 dollars, while nine salaries at the median would come to 342,000 dollars and understate the budget by 153,000 dollars.

  7. (a) The median, 3 days, with the IQR of 4 days. The mean of 6.4 days is above Q3=6Q_3 = 6 days, so about three quarters of the stays were shorter than it. (b) IQR=4IQR = 4 days and 1.5×IQR=61.5 \times IQR = 6 days, so the fences are −4-4 and 12 days: the 96-day maximum is an outlier, and no stay can be below a negative fence. (c) Settled: a long right tail, with the mean pulled past Q3Q_3 and ss nearly double the IQR. Left open: the number of peaks, which no set of summary statistics can show.

  8. (a) Mean 35.5 comments, median 28.5 comments, s≈26.24s \approx 26.24 comments, IQR=7IQR = 7 comments. (b) Report the median and the IQR: the 118-comment post is an outlier past the 42.5 fence and it pushes the mean above 11 of the 12 posts. (c) Without it, mean 28, median 28, s≈3.82s \approx 3.82, IQR=6IQR = 6 comments, so the mean fell 7.5 against the median's 0.5 and ss fell by a factor of about 6.9 against the IQR's 1 comment. (d) False. Problem 3 has a mean and median 0.3 minutes apart with two separated clusters and no commute within 15 minutes of either center.

The key gives final answers only. The full worked solution for each problem is on the matching practice set, and every other sheet is on the worksheets page.

More worksheets from this unit