Resistant statistic

By Jude Wallis · Published

A resistant statistic is a numerical summary whose value changes little when a few of the observations are extreme, so outliers cannot pull it far.

A statistic is resistant when moving a few observations arbitrarily far barely changes its value. Resistance belongs to the statistic, not to the data: the same numbers can carry a resistant summary and a nonresistant one at once. The median, the quartiles, and the IQR are resistant. The mean xˉ\bar{x} (x-bar), the standard deviation ss, and the range are not.

Take 21, 23, 24, 26, 28, 30, 31, 33, 36. The mean is 252/9=28252/9 = 28, the median is the fifth value, also 28, and s=4.95s = 4.95. Change the 36 to 96. The median stays at 28, Q1Q_1 at 23.5 and Q3Q_3 at 32, so the IQR is still 8.5, while the mean climbs to 312/9=34.67312/9 = 34.67 and ss to 23.33, almost five times over. Only the summaries that read magnitudes moved.

"The median is resistant, so it is the better measure of center" does not follow. Resistance is stability, not accuracy: a resistant summary buys it by refusing to look at how far the extreme values actually are. On a roughly symmetric distribution with no outliers, the mean uses more of the information and is what t procedures are built on. It is a reason to switch summaries when the shape calls for it, not a ranking.

Resistant is not a spare word for robust. Resistant describes a statistic: how much its value moves when a few observations are extreme. Robust describes a procedure: whether it still performs as advertised when a condition is only approximately met, the sense in which t procedures tolerate mild non-normality. AP does not keep them apart: topic 1.7 writes "a resistant (or robust) measure of center", so on the exam the two words point at one idea.

Resistance has a limit. A value already beyond a quartile can move further out without touching Q1Q_1 or Q3Q_3, but one pulled from inside a half does move it: in 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 the third quartile is 6.5, and changing the 5 to 100 raises it to 7.5. Once more than a quarter of the data sits far out on one side, that quartile moves too.

Where this comes up

More describing data terms, or browse the full statistics glossary.